Wyoming: Famous Arrest Cases Throughout History

Wyoming famous arrests records

Wyoming has a rich history of famous arrest cases that have captivated the nation’s attention. From notorious criminals to unsolved mysteries, the state has seen its fair share of intriguing incidents. Let’s take a closer look at some of Wyoming’s most notable arrests and the impact they’ve had on the state.

Key Takeaways:

  • Andrew Pixley’s murder of three young girls at Jackson’s Wort Hotel in 1964.
  • Earl Durand’s rampage in 1939, resulting in the deaths of five people.
  • Jack McCall’s arrest in Laramie for the assassination of Wild Bill Hickok.
  • The tragic car crash that claimed the lives of actress Judy Tyler and her husband in 1957.
  • The legendary case of Polly Bartlett, the alleged serial killer known as the “Murderess of Slaughterhouse Gulch.”
  • Unsolved murder cases and disappearances, including Susie Weaver, Mary Virginia Webb, and Stuart Isaac.
  • Wyoming’s relatively low homicide rate of 2.2 murders per 100,000 population in 2019.

Notable Cases in Wyoming’s History

From heinous murders to legendary criminals, Wyoming has seen its fair share of notable arrest cases. Throughout its history, the state has been home to intriguing crimes, captivating investigations, and unforgettable outcomes. Let’s explore some of the most significant cases that have left an indelible mark on Wyoming.

“The past is never dead. It’s not even past.” – William Faulkner

The Pixley Case: A Gruesome Tragedy

In 1964, the picturesque town of Jackson was shaken to its core by a shocking crime. Andrew Pixley, an itinerant dishwasher, brutally murdered three young girls at the renowned Wort Hotel. The community was left in a state of disbelief, and the subsequent investigation captured the attention of the nation. Pixley was eventually apprehended, convicted, and sentenced to death in Wyoming’s gas chamber. His heinous acts forever serve as a reminder of the darkness that can lurk even in the most idyllic of places.

The Durand Rampage: A Trail of Destruction

The year was 1939 when Earl Durand, a mountain man with a troubled past, embarked on a murderous rampage in Wyoming. Taking the lives of five innocent people, Durand spread fear and devastation throughout the region. The violent spree came to an end when he was confronted and ultimately shot by a courageous teenager. The Durand case stands as a testament to the resilience and determination of Wyoming’s communities when faced with unimaginable tragedy.

The Infamous McCall: Killing Wild Bill Hickok

In the annals of Western lore, the name Jack McCall looms large. In 1876, McCall infamously gunned down Wild Bill Hickok during a poker game in Deadwood, South Dakota. After fleeing the scene, McCall was captured in Laramie, Wyoming, where he admitted to the murder. This sensational case not only brought attention to the lawless frontier of the time but also revealed the lengths to which justice would be sought for the fallen hero of the Wild West.

  1. Tragic Incidents
  2. Unsolved Mysteries

Tragic Incidents: Lives Cut Short

Wyoming’s history is not only marked by notorious crimes but also by heartbreaking tragedies. In 1957, the promising actress Judy Tyler and her husband met a tragic end in a car crash that shocked the nation. This devastating incident serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of life and the often-unpredictable nature of fate. Another enigmatic case is that of Polly Bartlett, known as the “Murderess of Slaughterhouse Gulch.” While the events surrounding her arrest and death are shrouded in legend, her story remains a haunting part of Wyoming’s dark folklore.

Unsolved Mysteries: Seeking Answers

Wyoming’s vast landscapes have witnessed mysterious disappearances and unsolved murder cases. Susie Weaver, Mary Virginia Webb, and Stuart Isaac are just a few of the individuals who vanished without a trace, leaving behind unanswered questions and grieving loved ones. These unresolved mysteries continue to fuel the quest for justice and closure, as communities refuse to forget those who have been lost.

Year Homicide Rate per 100,000 Population
2019 2.2

While Wyoming’s crime statistics consistently show a relatively low homicide rate, the impact of famous arrest cases cannot be underestimated. They have shaped the state’s collective memory, leaving an imprint on its identity. From the notorious to the unsolved, these cases remind us of the complex nature of human behavior and the pursuit of justice.

Unsolved Mysteries and Tragic Incidents

Beyond the famous arrest cases, Wyoming also has a haunting history of unsolved mysteries and tragic incidents. These captivating and unresolved stories continue to intrigue and capture the imagination of locals and visitors alike.

One such mystery revolves around Susie Weaver, a young woman who vanished without a trace in 1952. Despite extensive search efforts and ongoing investigations, her disappearance remains unsolved to this day. The mystery surrounding her fate has become a topic of fascination, with various theories and speculations circulating within the community.

In another tragic incident, Mary Virginia Webb, a promising young artist, was brutally murdered in her home in Cheyenne in 1930. The case shocked the community and the state, but the perpetrator was never apprehended. Webb’s murder remains one of Wyoming’s most perplexing and heartbreaking unsolved crimes.

Stuart Isaac, a rancher from Sheridan, mysteriously vanished in 1994, leaving behind only unanswered questions. Despite extensive search efforts and ongoing investigations, no trace of Isaac has ever been found. His disappearance continues to haunt his family and friends, leaving them grasping for answers and closure.

Unsolved Mysteries in Wyoming
Case Date Location
Susie Weaver 1952 Unknown
Mary Virginia Webb 1930 Cheyenne
Stuart Isaac 1994 Sheridan

These cases are just a glimpse into the unsolved mysteries that have left a lasting impact on Wyoming. The state’s rugged and vast landscapes have proven to be a mysterious backdrop for these tragic events, leaving investigators, families, and communities longing for answers and closure.

Crime Statistics and Conclusion

Understanding the broader context, crime statistics in Wyoming shed light on the impact of these famous arrest cases. In 2019, Wyoming had a relatively low homicide rate of about 2.2 murders per 100,000 population. This statistic illustrates the overall safety of the state, despite the presence of infamous criminal cases throughout its history.

While Wyoming’s famous arrest cases have captivated public attention, they should not overshadow the fact that the majority of the state’s residents live peaceful lives. However, these cases have left a lasting impression on Wyoming’s collective memory and have shaped the state’s criminal justice system.

For those interested in exploring the criminal history of Wyoming, searching for mugshots or conducting criminal records searches can provide valuable insights. These resources allow you to understand the gravity of famous arrest cases and their impact on the state’s historical narrative. By acknowledging these cases, Wyoming can better understand its past and work towards a safer future.

Unsolved Mysteries and Ongoing Investigations

Wyoming is not without its share of unsolved mysteries and tragic incidents. The cases of Susie Weaver, Mary Virginia Webb, and Stuart Isaac continue to baffle investigators, leaving their families and communities seeking closure. As the search for answers persists, these cases serve as a somber reminder of the lingering pain caused by unresolved crimes.

In conclusion, Wyoming’s famous arrest cases, tragic incidents, and unsolved mysteries reflect the complexities of the human experience. They remind us of the importance of justice, the fragility of life, and the resilience of communities. By remembering and learning from these cases, Wyoming continues to evolve and strive for a safer and more just society.


Q: Are the famous arrest cases mentioned in this article real?

A: Yes, all of the famous arrest cases mentioned in this article are real and have occurred in Wyoming’s history.

Q: What happened to Andrew Pixley after he was convicted?

A: Andrew Pixley was convicted of murdering three young girls in Jackson’s Wort Hotel in 1964. He was sentenced to death and executed in Wyoming’s gas chamber.

Q: Who was Earl Durand and what did he do?

A: Earl Durand was a mountain man who went on a rampage in 1939, killing five people. He was eventually shot and killed by a teenager.

Q: Who arrested Jack McCall, the assassin of Wild Bill Hickok?

A: Jack McCall, the assassin of Wild Bill Hickok, was arrested in Laramie in 1876 and admitted to the murder.

Q: What happened to actress Judy Tyler and her husband?

A: Actress Judy Tyler and her husband died in a car crash in 1957, tragically claiming their lives.

Q: Who was Polly Bartlett and why is she of interest?

A: Polly Bartlett was an alleged serial killer known as the “Murderess of Slaughterhouse Gulch.” The events surrounding her arrest and death are steeped in legend.

Q: Are there any unsolved murder cases in Wyoming?

A: Yes, there are several unsolved murder cases in Wyoming’s history, including the cases of Susie Weaver, Mary Virginia Webb, and Stuart Isaac.

Q: What is the homicide rate in Wyoming?

A: In 2019, Wyoming had a relatively low homicide rate of about 2.2 murders per 100,000 population.

Source Links